And the answers are:

(1) They were cookies but looked nothing like the can including appearance and actual ingredients. Some of the cookies were strawberry raisin. Others were regular raisin and a third looked like cherries.

(2) Shower gel. Aimee figured it was something else the first time she used it. Ryan just thought it was a little stickier than other varieties and used it every so often. Sure enough, after Aimee sniffed out a problem, Ryan was able to magically create suds out of his hands in the sink.

(3) Yogurt. Perhaps Ryan could have known when he purchased that it was not milk as the picture on the front, when you look close, shows it 'flowing' more like yogurt.

Thanks to our contestants on their guesses. The products have been relocated to new homes that better match their intended usage. (Who wants the strawberry raisin cookies?)